KATHLEEN SQUIRES, MD: It's very clear that for people who present with advanced disease, who have very low CD4 cell counts or T4 counts, and have developed an opportunistic infection, those people need immediate therapy.
What's not so clear is when you were defined earlier in the disease, where your CD4 cell counts are more intact, meaning in the 300-500 range, and have modest viral loads. There again, the risk benefit analysis is something that really comes into play.
ANNOUNCER: It's in that gray zone where clinicians and their patients must weigh the advantages and disadvantages of early treatment.
KATHLEEN SQUIRES, MD: It is clear that ongoing, unchecked viral replication does affect the immune system and will cause progressive deterioration in the immune system. We do know that when we start therapy, we can get some "reconstitution" or rebuilding of the immune system. So the major reason that people really push early therapy is to try and preserve as much immunologic function as possible.
ANDREW CARR, MD: The advantages of starting treatment early is clearly preventing progression, keeping people well and truly away from illness.
KATHLEEN SQUIRES, MD: In terms of reasons to start therapy, it is clear that if you don't start drugs until patients have advanced disease-again, maybe they've developed an opportunistic infection or they have a low CD4 cell count, their response to therapy is simply not as good.
ANNOUNCER: Clinicians say there are also reasons to delay the start of anti-retroviral therapy.
KATHLEEN SQUIRES, MD: In the mid-90s, when it became clear that combination cocktail HAART based regimens were making a dramatic difference in patient's lives, the feeling was that you start everybody on drugs as soon as you make the diagnosis of the infection.
It's now clear that while the drugs are very effective by themselves can not eradicate the infection. And what's also clear is as we use these drugs longer, there are side effects. There are toxicities. There are complications. So there has been a rethinking and decision to perhaps wait later in the disease process because the drugs still can give patients a very marked advantage once they're started.
ANNOUNCER: Deciding when to start anti-retroviral therapy is usually a difficult decision. But doctors have become adept at helping patients weigh many factors, to help determine when they should start this life-prolonging treatment.